Remember the buzz around Ruben Amorim for Liverpool? Turns out, the Reds’ strategic choice of Arne Slot looks like a masterstroke! While Anfield celebrates titles, Manchester United under Amorim is hitting new lows. Was Liverpool’s foresight the key to their glory?

Liverpool’s astute decision to appoint Arne Slot over Ruben Amorim has been profoundly justified by recent events in the Premier League, illustrating a crucial divergence in fortunes for both footballing giants.

Initially, following Jürgen Klopp’s departure announcement in January 2024, Liverpool had shown considerable interest in Amorim, then head coach of Sporting CP, as a potential successor. However, after extensive consideration and a rigorous selection process, the Anfield hierarchy ultimately opted for Feyenoord’s Arne Slot, while Manchester United later secured Amorim’s services in November 2024 after dismissing Erik ten Hag.

Several factors underpinned Liverpool’s choice, notably concerns over Amorim’s rigid 3-4-3 tactical system. The club felt this approach would not align seamlessly with the existing squad structure or the successful 4-3-3 formation established under Klopp. Slot, conversely, was already committed to a successful four-man backline, a system seen as more compatible with Liverpool’s playing philosophy.

Beyond tactical considerations, a substantial nearly £10 million buy-out clause for Ruben Amorim presented a significant financial hurdle for the Reds. Reports also suggested that Anfield officials were annoyed by what was perceived as premature media speculation regarding their interest, further contributing to their apprehension and ultimately swaying their decision.

Despite Liverpool’s clear reservations about the Portuguese manager’s fit, Manchester United proceeded with hiring Amorim, fully aware of his strong preference for a three-man defence. This high-stakes managerial appointment at Old Trafford marked a new chapter for the Red Devils, hoping for a return to glory.

Fast forward to the 2025/2026 season, and the contrasting fortunes of both clubs under their respective new managers could not be starker. Arne Slot has rapidly become a revered figure at Anfield, guiding Liverpool to the Premier League title and solidifying their position as reigning champions, earning widespread acclaim for his strategic acumen.

Meanwhile, Manchester United under Amorim has faced a tumultuous period, culminating in an embarrassing Carabao Cup exit at the hands of League Two side Grimsby Town and a disappointing 15th-place finish in the previous Premier League season. Amorim’s once-stellar reputation, built on two Primeira Liga titles, has seemingly diminished under the intense scrutiny of the English game.

His tenure at United has been marred by a meagre 35.6% win rate from 45 matches, despite significant transfer investments in players like Patrick Dorgu and Matheus Cunha. Amorim’s insistence on a back three, goalkeeping inconsistencies with both Andre Onana and Altay Bayindir, and reported fallouts with key senior players such as Marcus Rashford, who has since joined Barcelona on loan, have amplified scrutiny on his leadership.

With no victories in the current season and a challenging fixture list ahead, including matches against Arsenal, Burnley, and Manchester City, Amorim’s position at Old Trafford appears increasingly precarious. This starkly contrasts with Slot’s triumphant start at Liverpool, offering a compelling narrative of strategic foresight and the unpredictable nature of football management.