Well, well, well, it looks like Darren Aronofsky’s latest, ‘Caught Stealing,’ is already a critical darling! With Austin Butler leading the charge, critics are raving about this crime thriller. Ever wonder what happens when an ex-baseball player babysits a cat and gets tangled with gangsters?

Darren Aronofsky’s highly anticipated new crime movie, *Caught Stealing*, has swiftly captivated critics, making an impressive debut with overwhelmingly positive early reviews. The Austin Butler-led feature has not only garnered significant buzz but also secured a Certified Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes, firmly establishing its status as a critical success from the outset.

This critically acclaimed crime thriller plunges into the tumultuous misadventures of Hank Thompson, a former baseball player portrayed by the charismatic Austin Butler. His life takes an unexpected turn when a seemingly innocent favor—babysitting his neighbor’s cat—catapults him into the crosshairs of a dangerous gangster crew, setting the stage for a compelling narrative.

Among the chorus of praise for *Caught Stealing*, Joanna Langfield highlighted the film’s enjoyable “caper-esque newest” qualities. She specifically lauded Austin Butler’s performance, emphasizing how the 34-year-old actor “proves in each and every scene, he is, indeed, a star,” further solidifying the strong movie reviews for the production.

Dionar Hidalgo, contributing to the positive sentiment surrounding the crime thriller, awarded the film a 7 out of 10, noting Aronofsky’s venture into “Tarantino and Ritchie territory with chaotic energy and dark humor.” Hidalgo further praised Austin Butler’s “magnetic performance,” asserting that his acting grounds the movie while keeping it both “watchable and fun.”

Jonathan Sim echoed the general sentiment, acknowledging that while *Caught Stealing* might not “reach the artistic heights of Aronofsky’s best work,” it nevertheless stands out as a “smart, well-paced, and fun ride through a version of New York that feels authentic and alive.” He underscored the film’s “unpredictability and strong performances” as key elements that make it a worthwhile watch for audiences seeking fresh movie reviews.

Further adding to the film’s critical acclaim, Avi Offer simply described Darren Aronofsky’s latest directorial effort as “an exhilarating, outrageously wildly entertaining ride,” contributing to the soaring Rotten Tomatoes score that has captivated public attention.

With such robust endorsement from critics, Caught Stealing has triumphantly achieved a Certified Fresh score of 84% on Rotten Tomatoes. This impressive rating is currently based on reactions from 64 critics, a number expected to increase as more reviewers weigh in on this gripping crime thriller.

Complementing Austin Butler, the Caught Stealing movie boasts a stellar supporting cast that includes renowned actors such as Regina King, Zoë Kravitz, Matt Smith, Liev Schreiber, Vincent D’Onofrio, and music sensation Bad Bunny, among others. Fans can mark their calendars as this star-studded feature is set to hit theaters on August 29, 2025.