Remember when Ruben Amorim was linked with Liverpool? The Reds chose Arne Slot, and his start has been stellar. Meanwhile, Amorim’s tenure at Manchester United is spiraling fast. Was Liverpool’s rejection a stroke of genius, or just pure luck? The results speak for themselves!
The divergent paths taken by Liverpool and Manchester United in their recent managerial appointments have unfolded dramatically, offering a stark lesson in strategic decision-making. What initially appeared to be a mere choice between high-profile candidates has blossomed into a glaring contrast of fortunes in the highly competitive Premier League.
Following the departure of a club legend, Liverpool’s search for a new head coach initially saw Ruben Amorim, then of Sporting CP, emerge as a leading contender. Widespread reports indicated significant interest from Anfield in the Portuguese tactician, positioning him as a strong candidate for one of football’s most coveted roles.
However, the Reds ultimately opted against pursuing Amorim, citing several critical concerns that shaped their strategic direction. A perceived rigid tactical system, potential incompatibility with the existing squad, a substantial buy-out clause, and even reported irritation over premature media coverage of their interest reportedly influenced Liverpool’s decision to explore other avenues.
A primary point of contention centered on Amorim’s unwavering preference for a 3-4-3 formation, a system he deftly adapted into a 4-2-4 in transition, a 5-2-3 defensively, and a 3-2-5 in attack. Liverpool’s hierarchy, accustomed to the successful 4-3-3 setup of their previous era, harbored doubts that their current personnel could effectively transition to a back-three dependent system without a costly squad overhaul.
In stark contrast, Arne Slot, who ultimately secured the coveted Liverpool managerial position, championed a back-four approach, notably his effective 4-2-4 system proven in the Eredivisie. His tactical philosophy was deemed a more seamless and compatible fit for the squad inherited, requiring less radical restructuring and aligning closely with the club’s established playing style and long-term ambitions.
Meanwhile, Manchester United proceeded with Amorim, seemingly undeterred by the very tactical and financial concerns that had swayed Liverpool. His tenure at Old Trafford has since seen his once-rising stock, built on two Primeira Liga titles with Sporting, plummet dramatically. United concluded the previous season in a disappointing 15th place under his guidance, endured a cup final defeat, and currently registers a paltry 35.6% win rate.
Despite significant transfer funds being made available, Amorim’s steadfast insistence on a back-three system at United, compounded by reported issues with key personnel, has led to a concerning defensive record, with 44 goals conceded during his relatively short spell. A noticeable lack of tactical evolution and discernible improvement on the pitch has prompted widespread questioning from former club legends and frustrated fans alike.
This season has offered no immediate respite for United, commencing with a home defeat and an underwhelming draw, facing intensified pressure as they approach a challenging fixture schedule. Conversely, Liverpool, under Slot, has enjoyed a flawless start to their campaign, securing two victories from two matches and now gearing up for an early title showdown. The starkly contrasting fortunes undoubtedly vindicate Liverpool’s astute strategic planning and their decision to opt for a different, ultimately more successful, managerial path.
