Manchester United have spent an eye-watering £1.9 billion on transfers since Sir Alex Ferguson retired, yet a Premier League title still eludes them. From promising talents to outright flops, we’ve ranked every single signing. Which player do you think was the biggest disappointment to don the red shirt?

Since the iconic departure of Sir Alex Ferguson in 2013, Manchester United has embarked on an unprecedented spending spree, investing a staggering £1.9 billion on new players. This monumental financial outlay, intended to recapture past glories, has paradoxically coincided with a barren spell in the Premier League, leaving fans and pundits alike questioning the club’s transfer strategy in the post-Ferguson era.

The sheer scale of this investment, spread across 74 distinct player acquisitions, paints a vivid picture of a club desperately striving for success. Yet, despite the nearly £2 billion committed to new talent, the ultimate prize of a Premier League title has consistently eluded the Red Devils, leading to widespread scrutiny of individual player performances and the club’s recruitment acumen.

Among the multitude of arrivals at Old Trafford, several high-profile signings have tragically failed to meet expectations, earning them a place among the most significant football transfer flops. Players like Antony, initially touted as a game-changer, and Rasmus Hojlund, a significant investment, struggled to deliver, leaving fans with a sense of disappointment. Similarly, talents such as Memphis Depay and Radamel Falcao arrived with immense reputations but departed without leaving a lasting positive impact.

The defensive spine and goalkeeping positions have also seen considerable investment, with varying degrees of success. André Onana’s arrival, intended to be a decisive upgrade, has unfortunately been marred by high-profile errors, continuing a trend of instability in a crucial area. This highlights the recurring challenge for Manchester United transfers in finding consistent quality that can withstand the immense pressure of English football.

Beyond the headline figures, numerous other Old Trafford signings made little impact, contributing to the overall underwhelming return on investment. The likes of Donny van de Beek, Daniel James, and Eric Bailly, while demonstrating flashes of potential, ultimately failed to secure regular starting berths or justify their price tags, becoming part of the long list of player rankings that illustrate the club’s struggles.

Even established stars like Paul Pogba, returning for a world-record fee, and Raphaël Varane, a decorated European champion, could not consistently elevate the team, with their tenures often plagued by inconsistency or injury. These complex Manchester United transfers underscore the difficulty in integrating even world-class talent into a struggling system, reflecting a broader issue with team cohesion and strategic direction in the Premier League spending era.

Amidst the numerous disappointments, a select few have managed to carve out more positive legacies. Zlatan Ibrahimović’s impactful, albeit brief, spell, Casemiro’s initially transformative presence, and Bruno Fernandes’ consistent creative output stand out as rare successes. Additionally, figures like Lisandro Martínez and Amad Diallo have shown promising signs, offering glimmers of hope in an otherwise challenging period for the club’s recruitment.

Ultimately, the analysis of Manchester United’s post-Ferguson transfer dealings reveals a profound disconnect between monumental Premier League spending and tangible on-field success. The club’s journey through a labyrinth of costly acquisitions and football transfer flops continues, with the aspiration for consistent excellence at Old Trafford remaining a fervent desire, yet an elusive reality.