Premier League bosses took the Carabao Cup as a chance to shake things up, making an incredible 95 combined changes! Some gambled with entire new line-ups, while others made just a few tweaks. Did these bold decisions pay off, or did they lead to early cup exits? Find out which teams progressed and which faced disappointment.

This week’s Carabao Cup action saw an unprecedented wave of squad rotation as Premier League managers embraced wholesale changes, demonstrating a clear strategic shift in approach to cup competitions. Many top-flight teams used the domestic cup as an opportunity to rest key players and give valuable minutes to fringe players or rising stars, leading to a remarkable 95 combined alterations across the 11 participating Premier League sides.

Leading this trend were Brighton, Burnley, and Sunderland, whose managers Fabian Hurzeler, Scott Parker, and Regis Le Bris, respectively, opted for entirely new starting elevens. These bold managerial decisions against Oxford, Derby, and Huddersfield, highlighted a willingness to gamble on depth and fresh legs, showcasing the growing importance of squad management in the demanding English football calendar.

The increasing propensity for Premier League clubs to make extensive adjustments for cup ties reflects a broader tactical discussion within football tactics. Coaches often weigh the benefits of player welfare and developing squad harmony against the immediate competitive goals of progression in a knockout tournament, creating a fascinating dynamic each time the draw is made.

While widespread changes were common, not all managers followed suit so dramatically. Graham Potter, for instance, introduced the fewest fresh faces with just four alterations for his side’s clash against Wolves. Despite this more conservative approach, his team unfortunately succumbed to a third consecutive defeat across all competitions, illustrating that even minor tweaks don’t guarantee success.

Conversely, Bournemouth manager Andoni Iraola made nine changes following a league victory, only to see his side slip to a 2-0 defeat against Brentford, ending their Carabao Cup journey prematurely. This outcome underscored the inherent risks associated with such extensive adjustments, particularly when integrating multiple players who may lack recent match sharpness together.

However, squad rotation proved a winning formula for some. Scott Parker’s Burnley, after a full overhaul for their tie against Championship side Derby, secured progression to the third round. Early goals and a stoppage-time winner demonstrated the potential for refreshed players to deliver strong performances, reinforcing the validity of the strategy when executed effectively.

Yet, the gamble did not pay off for Sunderland’s Regis Le Bris. His decision to rotate every player ultimately backfired as the Black Cats were knocked out by League One Huddersfield after a tense penalty shoot-out. This result highlighted the fine margins involved and the potential for a lack of cohesion to impact critical moments in a cup tie.

Similarly, Leeds manager Daniel Farke retained only two starters from a recent heavy league defeat, only to see his Premier League side fall behind and eventually exit the competition after a penalty shoot-out loss to crisis-hit Championship opposition. These contrasting outcomes across the competition’s second round underscore the complex balance Premier League managers must strike between progress and player management.